What Should I Do If My Chilled Cookie Dough Is Too Hard? 4 Excellent Options

Rate this post

What Should You Do If Your Cookie Dough Is Too Hard?

Cookies are simple to prepare and can be done by virtually anybody. Most recipes take little more than half an hour to complete, making it everyone’s favorite quick sweet snack.

Yet there are times when you want your cookies in 10 minutes or less, not 30. What are you going to do? Easy!

Prepare a large quantity and save the unbaked cookie dough in the fridge for 3 to 5 days (or up to 3 months in the freezer) in case of cookie cravings.

So you have some refrigerated cookie dough, and you suddenly have a cookie desire.

You preheat your oven, prepare your baking sheet, and take the cookie out of the fridge or freezer, only to find that it has hardened into a giant, rock-hard block of dough that you can’t deal with. Your refrigerated cookie dough has become too firm. What are you going to do?


My Chilled Cookie Dough Is Too Hard- What To Do?

If your refrigerated cookie dough becomes too firm, you have four options. To begin, put it in a warm location (like as beside a heated stove) to soften. Second, if it’s soft enough to cut with a knife, chop it into smaller bits to speed up the thawing process. Finally, thaw it in the microwave in 5-10 second bursts at the lowest setting possible, until just soft enough to deal with. Fourth, put the dough in a basin and set it over another dish filled with boiling water. This permits the dough to soften without being exposed to direct heat.

How Do I Thaw Chilled Cookie Dough That Is Too Hard?

Several ideas for thawing out your too-hard cookie dough are provided below.

1. Place in a warm place

Put your cookie dough in a warm spot, such as near to a hot stove, to allow it to soften. When they’re soft enough to deal with, you can start preparing them for baking.

2. Cut Into Smaller Chunks

If the dough is soft enough to cut with a knife, divide it into smaller, more manageable bits. This allows them to thaw more quickly rather than waiting for a large amount of dough to defrost.

3. Defrost in the Microwave

This procedure should be used with caution since it has the potential to destroy your cookie dough. Place the dough in a microwave-safe basin and thaw in 5-10 second bursts on the lowest setting available.

The small intervals ensure that we do not overheat the dough and just thaw it until it is ready to deal with.

If we overheat it, we risk melting the fats in our dough, defeating the point of chilling in the first place, or worse, frying our dough.

4. Place dough in a bowl and put over another bowl with hot water

This permits the dough to soften without the need of a direct heat source. But, like with the microwave approach, we must be cautious not to overheat it.

Why Do We Chill Cookie Dough?

Cookie dough is refrigerated for a number of reasons, including convenience, texture improvement, and flavor development.

1. To Develop Flavor

Several recipes ask for chilling cookie dough in order to enhance and intensify the tastes. When the dry components combine with the liquid ingredients, chemical reactions occur, allowing the dough to hydrate and absorb all of the varied flavors you add, resulting in a cookie with a richer, more nuanced taste.

2. To Improve Texture

Butter not only adds a particular taste and perfume to cookies, but it also has a significant impact on their final look and texture.

Cooling cookie dough causes the fat to firm, which means that when you bake them, they will not spread as much and will retain their structure.

If you skip the chilling step and bake your cookies straight away, you may wind up with flatter cookies, particularly if the butter is beginning to melt. Flat cookies are also prone to burning.

3. For Convenience

As previously said, sometimes you simply want a cookie right now.

Having refrigerated cookie dough on hand at all times greatly reduces the time it takes between craving a cookie and enjoying a freshly baked cookie.

How to Chill Cookie Dough

Cookie dough may be cooled in the fridge or the freezer, depending on your needs and timetable.

If you’re merely chilling the dough to develop taste and texture, and if you want to bake the cookies within 3-5 days, you may keep them in the fridge.

If you want to keep it for longer, or if you produced a large amount that you won’t be able to finish in 3-5 days, your best chance is to put it in the freezer. Cookie dough may be stored in the freezer for up to three months.

Tips for Properly Chilling or Freezing Cookie Dough

Are you prepared to relax? Continue reading for more helpful hints.

1. Freeze dough in airtight containers or freezer bags

To keep your cookie dough fresh and prevent it from absorbing tastes from other foods in your fridge or freezer, store it in an airtight container or freezer bag.

You don’t want your chocolate chip cookies to taste like the curries you ate for supper the night before. (But, if you’re interested, you can create curry-flavored cookies, just not in this method.)

2. Freeze In Smaller Workable portions

To prevent having to thaw a large lump of dough, particularly if you only need a few cookies, freeze or store the dough in little, manageable quantities.

You may previously split them into little balls before freezing or storing them, so that when cookie cravings strike, you can just drop them on a baking pan and bake away.

When you’ve made your dough, split it into little balls and place them on a baking sheet. Freeze for about 15-20 minutes. After the dough balls have hardened enough, you may place them in freezer bags without fear of them sticking together.

3. Cover well with plastic wrap to avoid freezer burn

If you wish to freeze your dough without portioning it, shape it into a flatter disk rather than a big ball.

That not only saves freezer space, but it also allows them to defrost quicker and more uniformly when you’re ready to bake them.

To prevent freezer burn, be sure to thoroughly cover the dough in plastic wrap.

4. Make sure that the dough for the specific cookie you are making can be frozen

Most cookie doughs can be refrigerated or frozen for extended periods of time without affecting their texture or flavor when baked; they will still taste as fresh as if you had just made them.

Nevertheless, there are several exceptions.

Cookies with thinner batters or cookies with little fat, such as Florentine cookies and Tuiles, do not hold up well to freezing or cooling for an extended period of time.

But, most other cookie doughs may be safely refrigerated.

5. Make sure raw cookie dough is properly wrapped to avoid cross-contamination

Be sure to wrap your cookie dough carefully and keep it apart from food that will not be prepared prior to eating, such as salads or fruits, as well as your chocolates and other snacks.

Raw eggs may contain deadly germs such as Salmonella, so keep your dough apart from other foods in your fridge or freezer to avoid cross-contamination.

Can You Eat Raw Cookie Dough?

I confess that I have done this once or twice, but it is not something I would suggest.

Raw eggs may contain hazardous germs such as Salmonella, putting you at risk of food-borne disease.

If you must eat raw cookie dough, you can probably make cookies without using raw eggs.

Currently, there are several substitutes that may be used in recipes to simulate the binding function of eggs.

Nutrients such as flax seeds, chia seeds, and psyllium husk are also worth investigating since they offer several health advantages.

One of my favorite cookie recipes is egg-free and vegan-friendly, and I swear it takes a lot of effort not to devour the whole bowl before baking them!

Conclusion to Chilled Cookie Dough Too Hard – What to Do?

If your cookie dough is excessively firm, it may seem to be a major catastrophe, particularly if you are in the midst of a cookie yearning emergency.

Nevertheless, as we’ve seen, there are many things you can do to quickly rectify the problem, as well as other things you can do to make things simpler to manage the next time.

Even if we have to put in a little more work, the advantages of cooling are well worth it!

Frequently Asked Questions to Chilled Cookie Dough Too Hard – What to Do?

Is the fridge or the freezer a better option for chilling cookie dough?

Depending on your time constraints, you may chill your cookie dough in both the refrigerator and the freezer. When properly kept, cookie dough will survive for approximately 3-5 days in the refrigerator and up to 3 months in the freezer.

Should I wait for chilled cookie dough to thaw completely before baking?

In general, cookie dough may be cooked right from the freezer or fridge, eliminating the need to wait for it to get to room temperature. They may just need to cook for a few minutes longer to compensate for the cooler temperature at the start.

Can all kinds of cookie dough be frozen?

Most cookie doughs may be frozen and baked later without substantial loss of quality or flavor, however particular cookies, such as tuiles and Florentine cookies, do not stand up well to freezing or storage for an extended period of time.


What to do if chilled cookie dough is too hard?

How to Soften Refrigerated Cookie Dough
Merrill suggests placing the dough on a hot burner and pressing it with a rolling pin as it begins to soften.
Trena uses a pastry cutter to cut the dough into smaller pieces so that it may come to room temperature quicker.
Additional information…•December 28, 2013

How do you soften chilled cookie dough?

Let the dough to warm up at room temperature until it is slightly malleable (about 5 to 10 minutes). Allowing it to become too warm will negate the goal of freezing the dough entirely.

How do you soften hardened dough?

If your dough is still too stiff after kneading, move it closer to a heat source.
You may put them on a radiator for a few minutes, under a lamp (near the light bulb), rapidly heat them up with a hair dryer, or in the microwave oven for a few seconds in defrosting mode.

What can I do with cookies that are too hard?

The simplest approach to soften those hard cookies is to use something you already have in your kitchen… bread! That’s correct, a slice of fresh bread will soften and chewy those tough goodies.

Why did my cookies get hard after cooling?

They transition from soft to hard because they begin to dry out as soon as you remove them from the oven. (Yikes.) Whatever moisture remains in the cookies is constantly evaporating. Simultaneously, the sugars and starches are hardening.

Can you microwave cookie dough to soften it?

You may soften cookie dough in the microwave, but be cautious not to overheat it. The dough should be soft enough to work with but not so baked that it becomes difficult to manage. If the dough is excessively soft, it will be difficult to shape and keep its shape when cooked.

Why is my dough hard after refrigeration?

Bread dough that has become firm after being refrigerated. If it just has a firm crust, you may take it off and utilize the remaining dough. If it’s too difficult, scrap it and start again. Any dough that is refrigerated should be in a firmly sealed container.

How do you make Pillsbury cookies soft again?

Reheat them in the microwave for 15 to 20 seconds on medium. This should give the cookies ample time to absorb the moisture from the paper towel. If they haven’t softened sufficiently when you take them out, wrap them in another moist paper towel and microwave for 10 seconds longer.

How do you soften frozen cookie dough quickly?

Thaw for at least one hour (up to overnight) in the refrigerator, then thaw on the counter for 30 minutes or so, until the dough is soft enough to lay out and bake as indicated in your recipe.

How do you revive hardened dough?

Brushing the surface of a drying dough with water is the best approach to mend it. You may apply it with a pastry brush or your fingertips. Brush the dry sections of the dough lightly with water, let aside for 15 minutes, and repeat. Continue until the dough is soft again.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *