What’s the deal with my flat Snickerdoodles? 3 Arguments

Rate this post

There are few things more stressful than laboring over a cookie dough only to find that when you bring it out of the oven, the completed result looks nothing like it should.

Numerous individuals have been burned by flat cookies. If you like snickerdoodles, keep reading to learn how to prevent flat snickerdoodles.

Why are my snickerdoodles flat?

Many missteps may result in a flat snickerdoodle. Overmixing the butter and sugar may result in a flat snickerdoodle. It’s also possible that you’re baking them at too low a temperature. Finally, the cookies may be flat because the dough was not refrigerated or cold enough before baking.

Reason 1: Overmixing your Sugar and Butter

Frequently, a cookie recipe will instruct you to combine the butter, sugar, and brown sugar at the start of the procedure.

Although it is critical that these components mix thoroughly, it is equally critical not to overmix.

Overmixing causes the butter to get overheated, resulting in a flat cookie when the cookies are baked.

A fine balance must be struck between mixing and overmixing.

Some people may find it difficult to find the correct quantity of mixing.

When discussing the combination of butter and sugar, recipes often use the term cream.

To correctly mix together the butter and sugars at the start of your cookie recipe, timing yourself.

To cream these items together, mix them for one or two minutes.

The softness of the butter is another important consideration when creaming it with the sugar.

Numerous recipes recommend using softened butter. If that’s the case, make sure the butter isn’t straight from the fridge.

One would assume that using cooler butter would assist, but cold butter needs you to combine the components more thoroughly.

Overmixing causes the butter to overheat as a result of the excessive pounding.

Avoiding overmixing the butter and sugar will help you prevent flat snickerdoodles.

Another typical oversight is the temperature at which the cookies are baked.

Reason 2: Oven Temperature

Even if you bake the cookies at the temperature specified in the recipe, this does not guarantee that it is the suitable temperature for your oven. If your cookies are consistently flat, adjusting the baking temperature may help.

Ovens are not all made equal, with some running hotter or colder than others. You could discover a better baking temperature for your oven if you raise the temperature from 350 degrees to 375 degrees.

Heating your cookies at a low temperature can melt the butter and cause the cookies to spread before the remainder of the dough has a chance to set. A higher baking temperature helps all cookie components bake quicker, allowing the cookie to firm up without spreading out.

If you suspect that your oven is too chilly, consider raising the temperature for your next batch. That could help your cookies puff up a little more.

Reason 3: Dough Temperature

Cookie recipes often instruct you to refrigerate the dough before baking. This is a critical stage that should not be overlooked. Chilling the dough before baking might be the difference between flat and fluffy cookies.

When the dough is chilled, it prevents the cookie from spreading too rapidly when it initially begins to bake. This results in a fluffier cookie and more uniform baking of the dough.

If the recipe does not call for it, I do not recommend chilling the dough. But, if the recipe specifies, the dough should be cooled to avoid flat cookies, so follow the recipe’s directions.

Further considerations for flat cookies

There are a few extra details to consider so that your cookies don’t turn out too flat. Checking the expiry date of your rising agents is one among them.

Check to see whether your cookies are turning out flat because of outdated baking soda or baking powder.

White sugar is another component that might cause your cookies to stretch out too much. When you use too much white sugar in your cookies, they will spread out.

Finally, if the dough has insufficient flour, the cookies will spread out flat.

Each of them may be prevented by verifying the expiry date on your ingredients and measuring accurately before mixing your dough.

Frequently Asked Questions About Why Are My Snickerdoodles Flat

Is it possible for your butter to be too soft?

While creating the dough, if your butter is too soft, the effects will be identical to overmixing your butter and sugar. So, yes, this is doable.

How long should I have my butter out before baking?

Remove the butter from the refrigerator a couple of hours before baking the cookies. This should soften the butter enough to allow it to cream nicely with the sugar. But, you do not want your butter to get too heated. Avoid putting it out the night before or leaving it outside on a hot day.


The trick is in the butter and being precise with your measures. There are several elements that might influence the amount of butter in your dough. To prevent flat snickerdoodles, practice excellent baking skills, use accurate measures, and make sure your dough and oven are both at the proper temperature before baking. Now go baking and create some fluffy snickerdoodles!


Why are my snickerdoodle cookies coming out flat?

If your cookies consistently come out flat, regardless of the recipe, your oven is probably too hot. Here’s what’s going on. In an overheated oven, the butter melts fast before the other ingredients have firmed up into a cookie structure. As a result, when the butter spreads, so does the whole liquidy biscuit.

How do you keep snickerdoodles from flattening?

How to Avoid Flat Snickerdoodle Cookies
You may have over-mixed your sugar and butter combination.
Your flour might be the source of the problem.
You may be baking them at an insufficient temperature.
Chill your dough until hard, then slice it before baking.
Dec 4, 2020

Why did my cookies flatten so much?

Since the fat in the cookie dough melts in the oven, cookies spread. The cookies will spread if there isn’t enough flour to retain the melted fat. Spoon and level your flour, or better yet, weigh it. If your cookies continue to spread, add an additional 2 tablespoons of flour to the cookie mixture.

How do I keep my cookies from going flat?

9 Things to Keep in Mind
Keep it cool and use real butter. Your cookies may be flat due to butter’s low melting point.
Shortening should be used…. Dough should be chilled twice…. Parchment paper or a silicone liner should be used.
Exact measurements…. Use fresh baking soda…. Optional add-ins.
Purchase an Oven Thermometer.
Additional information…•Oct 15, 2016

How do you fluff up flat cookies?

If your first batch of cookies comes out flat, add 1-2 teaspoons flour to the remaining dough. Then bake a test cookie before proceeding with the remainder of the cookies or adding a little extra flour.

Why do my cookies deflate when they cool?

What are the main reasons behind this? Steam and other heated gases that had been blowing up the cookies either escape or condensate. The cookies deflate because there is no heat to generate additional steam. Bread, quiches, and other baked items provide the same effect.

Why did my snickerdoodles not spread?

One of the most typical causes for cookies failing to spread in the oven is that you used too much flour. Cookies depend on the ideal butter-to-flour ratio to spread exactly the correct amount when cooked. By using cup measures, it is quite simple to overmeasure flour.

What happens if you forget baking soda in snickerdoodles?

If you leave out baking soda in a recipe that calls for it, your cookies will be exceptionally thick since there was no chemical reaction to introduce those gas bubbles and give it rise. What exactly is this? You could also discover that your cookies are considerably flatter than you expected.

Why won t my biscuits rise?

The longer you work with the dough, the warmer it gets. If the fat becomes too hot, it will melt into the flour and the cakes will not rise as tall. Thus, although it’s crucial to fold the dough a few times to produce layers, don’t go overboard and fold it too many times.

Why do my cookies puff up and then go flat?

Excessive use of baking soda.

Instead of baking soda, use baking powder. Baking soda promotes spreading, whilst baking powder puffs up the cookies. If your recipe asks for 1 teaspoon baking soda, add 3 to 4 teaspoons baking powder.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *